Get Off Those Maliciously Loaded Scripts!
Download this free Anti-Malware Plugin for WordPress.

I investigated further, and found that one of the quarantined files had not been fixed, it still had a big chunk of heavily obfuscated code in it. I assumed it was malware and removed it, it seems to have fixed the problem. Now checking other quarantined files.

I still am not sure how the plugin reports that the site did not break, when in fact the homepage returned an internal server error.

Thanks
kris